On Thursday, July 2, 2026, the board of the Buckhorn Valley Metropolitan District met to compare summer water use with the level of its reservoir. Its irrigation pumps draw from the Eagle River, and the river was too low to send water up to the reservoir. Starting the week of July 13, the district cut its irrigation deliveries to one day a week, Tuesdays, for the rest of the season. On the valley floor at Cotton Ranch, the raw-water system ran on its own posted schedule until the shutoff the district had set for October 15.
Both subdivisions are on the Town of Gypsum's list of neighborhoods that water their yards with separate, non-drinkable irrigation water instead of town water. The two systems still had very different summers. In Gypsum, knowing that a neighborhood has "HOA irrigation water" tells you little. The source behind that water decides how a yard does in a dry year, and 2026 followed a record-low snowpack.
Gypsum Keeps Two Water Lists
The town's water page sorts residential areas into two groups. Quail Run, Mountain Glen, Buckhorn Valley, Cotton Ranch, Sky Legend, Chatfield Corners, Brightwater and Stratton Flats have separate non-potable irrigation water supplied through an HOA or district. Some commercial and airport-area parks are also on that list. Willowstone, Eagle River Estates, Gypsum Estates, Estes Lane, Red Hill and Old Town water their yards with town potable water. Indoor water can come from a different provider than yard water. In Buckhorn Valley, for example, the district supplies the irrigation water and the Town of Gypsum supplies treated indoor water.
For a buyer comparing Gypsum homes, this splits the town along lines that a price filter won't show. Each neighborhood on the raw-water list also depends on its own provider and its own source.
Town Water Ran Under One Plan in 2026
The town-water neighborhoods went through the summer together. In March 2026, as Vail Daily reported, the Gypsum Town Council approved on first reading a new water shortage plan. Utilities Director Mike Hoffman told the paper the town was responding to the record-low snowpack, and the article named Cotton Ranch, Chatfield and Buckhorn among the subdivisions running their own irrigation water. By its fall newsletter the town was in Phase II, its first mandatory stage. It lifted all restrictions as of October 29, 2026.
Town water customers also paid more in 2026. The town raised its water base rate by 10% and each higher usage tier by 20%, effective January 2026. Wastewater rates went up 25% and sanitation rates 2% for the same year. Old Town, Willowstone and the other town-water neighborhoods all depended on the same town system that dry summer, so their yards went through it on the same terms.
Buckhorn Valley Depends on the Eagle River
Buckhorn Valley's season started well. The district's storage pond was full when the system came on for the community on Tuesday, May 12, 2026, and watering began under a declared drought schedule of two days a week, Tuesdays and Fridays.
The district's own notices show why the schedule tightened. The Eagle River refills the reservoir, and through the summer the river ran too low to pump. At two days a week, the district found, the reservoir would not last through the irrigation season, so the board declared a severe drought schedule and cut watering to Tuesdays. In a later update, with reservoir photos dated August 18, 2026, the district put the reservoir at about 20% of capacity and estimated weekly use at 5%. It warned that the watering season could end early.
Buckhorn's district kept residents updated through the summer, posting reservoir photos alongside its notices. The 2026 season shows how a reservoir that depends on pumping from the Eagle River holds up in a low-snow year, and anyone looking at a Buckhorn Valley yard should know that.
The newest Buckhorn homes are designed around this water. In April 2025, Gypsum approved a change that turned a multifamily-zoned section of the subdivision into 72 single-family modular homes of about 1,350 square feet, to be built in batches of about 20. According to Vail Daily's report on the approval, the district will supply raw water for their small back yards and the rest of the outdoor space will be xeriscaped. The developer's target price at the time was $740,000 to $750,000. The same article counted about 340 unbuilt lots left in Buckhorn Valley. The district's posted monthly irrigation rate for Buckhorn Valley, all phases, is $72.93, under a schedule marked effective April 1, 2024.
Cotton Ranch Draws From Gypsum Creek
Cotton Ranch gets its irrigation water from Gypsum Creek. The Cotton Ranch Metropolitan District says it holds water rights on the creek and diverts through the Chatfield Bartholomew ditch and the Grundell Brothers/AF Grundell ditches. Those ditches feed Red Fox Ponds and a pond near the lower pump house. The district shares this water with the golf course and the town. The golf course is Gypsum Creek Golf Course, an 18-hole Pete Dye design at 530 Cotton Ranch Drive. The district describes its Gypsum Creek rights as senior.
For 2026, the district said the valley floor and Sky Legend systems would be on by May 1. The lower bench and Sky Legend systems were scheduled to shut off October 15, 2026, and the district's turn-off notice asked owners to blow out their systems before the freeze. That was the same summer Buckhorn Valley spent on one watering day a week.
Cotton Ranch's 2026 fee schedule, billed for May through October, lists a $93 monthly base fee for the Lower Valley area. In Sky Legend the monthly base fee is $23.25 for Cottage and Traditional homes and $46.50 for Custom homes, and in the Villas at Cotton Ranch it is $23.25 per unit.
Chatfield Corners Bills a Flat Fee
Chatfield Corners Metropolitan District uses a different model. Its raw-water irrigation fee rises to $45 on January 1, 2027, to cover maintenance and future upgrades as the system ages. The district notes that the fee does not pay for water consumed. Billing is moving from the Town of Gypsum, which has handled it since the district began, to American Conservation & Billing Solutions, known as Amcobi, on a quarterly cycle.
So three raw-water subdivisions charge in three different ways: a flat fee at Chatfield Corners, base fees that vary by area and home type at Cotton Ranch, and a single posted monthly rate at Buckhorn Valley. These figures are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm current fees for any specific home with the district and the right professional.
Reading a Gypsum Listing for Its Water
When you compare two Gypsum homes at similar prices, the first useful question is which list the address is on. The second is who the provider is and where its water comes from. A creek-fed system with senior rights and a reservoir refilled from the Eagle River can both be on the "raw water" list and still behave very differently in a dry August, as 2026 showed. A home with a large lawn will feel that difference more than one with a small, partly xeriscaped yard. Buckhorn Valley's newest homes are built that way.
Cotton Ranch, Buckhorn Valley and Chatfield Corners all post notices on their district websites, and the 2026 notices show each system's turn-on date, any mid-season changes, its shutoff and its fees. Our Gypsum neighborhood page covers the town more broadly, and the water list is a good thing to have open next to it.
If you're weighing a Gypsum home, Team Black Bear can help you find out which water system serves it, how that system did in the summer of 2026 and what it costs to run before you make an offer. We're glad to help you get these answers early. Reach out whenever you're ready.